International Journal of Biotechnology and Computational Science

Reviewer Guidelines

For contributing your valuable expertise as a reviewer for the International Journal of Biotechnology and Computational Science (IJBCS). Your role is vital to maintaining the quality and integrity of the research we publish. Please carefully review the guidelines below to ensure an effective and fair peer-review process.

1. Responsibilities of Reviewers

  • Provide objective, constructive, and timely feedback to help authors improve their manuscripts.

  • Evaluate the originality, scientific rigor, clarity, and relevance of the submission.

  • Maintain confidentiality of all manuscript content and information during and after the review process.

  • Declare any conflicts of interest or potential biases before accepting a review request.

  • Recommend acceptance, revision, or rejection based on the manuscript's scientific merit and alignment with journal scope.

2. Review Process

  • IJBCS operates under a double-blind review system, meaning both reviewers and authors remain anonymous to each other.

  • Reviewers will receive all necessary materials through the online review system.

  • Typical review timeframe is 7-14 days. Prompt submission of your review is essential for efficient publication timelines.

3. Evaluation Criteria

When reviewing, please consider the following key aspects:

  • Originality: Is the research novel and does it add value to the field?

  • Methodology: Are the experimental design and methods appropriate and well-explained?

  • Data and Results: Are the data accurate, clearly presented, and well-analyzed?

  • Discussion and Conclusion: Are interpretations logical, and conclusions supported by data?

  • References: Are citations relevant, up-to-date, and sufficient?

  • Clarity: Is the manuscript well-organized and clearly written?

4. Providing Feedback

  • Be specific and provide detailed comments to help authors understand your recommendations.

  • Suggest constructive improvements without personal criticism.

  • Highlight any ethical concerns or potential plagiarism.

  • Use the reviewer form in the online system to submit your comments and final recommendation.

5. Confidentiality and Ethics

  • Manuscripts under review should not be shared or discussed with others without permission.

  • Do not use any information from the manuscript for personal gain or research before publication.

  • Adhere to ethical standards in all communications related to the review.

6. Reviewer Recognition and Credits

At IJBCS, we highly value the dedication and expertise of our reviewers. To acknowledge your essential contributions, we provide:

  • Reviewer Credits: Your reviewing activity is recorded in recognized databases, linking your professional profile with your peer-review work, enhancing your academic and professional reputation.

  • Certificates of Appreciation: Upon completing reviews, you will receive official certificates recognizing your valuable service to the scientific community.

  • Annual Acknowledgments: Reviewers who have made outstanding contributions will be publicly acknowledged on our website (with consent), celebrating your commitment to advancing science.

For any questions or support related to the review process, please contact the editorial office at:
Email: reviews@ijbcs.org